Search all the listings in this section
Browse by Category:|
|Is Akram Jomaa Islamic Centre Considered a Masjid or Musallah?
I have a question regarding actual status of Akram Jomaa Islamic Centre in Calgary. Does the centre fall under the definition of a Masjid or Musallah?
Praise be to Allah.
A masjid or mosque is a place which is prepared for the purpose of offering the five daily prayers on a permanent basis and is devoted for that purpose.
A place becomes a mosque when general permission is given to pray in it, whether it is stated clearly that it is a waqf or endowment given for the sake of Allah, or it is not stated, according to the majority of scholars apart from the Shaafa‘is. See: al-Mawsoo‘ah al-Fiqhiyyah, 37/220
Ibn Qudaamah (may Allah have mercy on him) said: A waqf is valid if it is established verbally or by means of actions which indicate that, such as if a person builds a mosque and give the people permission to pray in it, or he establishes a graveyard and gives people permission to bury the dead in it, because that is the custom and it indicates that something is a waqf. So it is permissible to establish it by means of that (action), as it may also be established verbally. That is like when a person presents food to his guests. End quote from al-Kaafi, 2/250
A mosque is no longer the property of the one who establishes it, because it is a waqf, so it is not permissible for him to sell it.
There are prayer rooms (musallas) that are set up in offices and schools; these do not come under the rulings on mosques because they are not established as waqfs and as such they do not cease to be the property of their owners. Moreover, the five daily prayers are not held regularly in them in most cases.
It says in Fataawa al-Lajnah ad-Daa’imah (5/169): What is the difference between a mosque (masjid) and a prayer room (musalla)? What I mean is: Is offering the prayer to greet the mosque (tahiyat al-masjid) obligatory in a prayer room or does it not come under that ruling? Or is it mustahabb and recommended?
A mosque (masjid) is a place that has been set aside for offering the obligatory prayers on a permanent basis and is devoted for that purpose. A prayer room or prayer place (musalla) is a place that is used for prayer occasionally, such as the ‘Eid prayers, funeral (janaazah) prayers and so on, and it is not set aside as a waqf for the five daily prayers. It is not Sunnah to offer the prayer to “greet the mosque” when entering a musalla; rather it is Sunnah to offer this prayer when entering a mosque for one who wants to sit down in the mosque; he should do it before he sits down, because the Prophet (blessings and peace of Allah be upon him) said: “When one of you enters the mosque, let him not sit down until he has prayed two rak‘ahs.” Saheeh - agreed upon.
And Allah is the source of strength. May Allah send blessings and peace upon our Prophet Muhammad and his family and companions. End quote.
Shaykh ‘Abd al-‘Azeez ibn ‘Abdullah ibn Baaz, Shaykh ‘Abdullah ibn Ghadyaan, Shaykh Saalih al-Fawzaan; Shaykh ‘Abd al-‘Azeez Aal ash-Shaykh, Shaykh Bakr Abu Zayd
Shaykh Ibn ‘Uthaymeen (may Allah have mercy on him) was asked about the difference between a mosque and a prayer room, and when a place may be regarded as a mosque.
He replied: With regard to the general meaning, the entire earth is a mosque because the Prophet (blessings and peace of Allah be upon him) said: “The earth has been made a place of prostration and a means of purification for me.”
With regard to the specific meaning, a mosque is a place that has been prepared for the purpose of prayer on a permanent basis and is allocated specifically for that, whether it is built of stones, mud or cement, or not. With regard to the prayer room or prayer place, it is a place that a person uses to pray in, but he does not make it a place for prayer on a permanent basis; rather he prays there if the time for prayer comes. This is not a mosque. The evidence for that is the fact that the Messenger (blessings and peace of Allah be upon him) used to offer naafil prayers in his house, and his house was not a mosque. Similarly, ‘Utbaan ibn Maalik invited him to come to his house and pray in a place that ‘Utbaan could take as a prayer room or prayer place, and that place was not a mosque. So a prayer room is a place that is used for prayer without it being set up specifically as a public mosque in which the people can pray and that is known to have been set up specifically for that purpose.
End quote from Fataawa ash-Shaykh Ibn ‘Uthaymeen, 12/394
From the above we may conclude that a mosque is a place that fulfils the following conditions:
1- It has been set aside as a waqf and is no longer the property of the one who established it
2- General permission to pray in it has been given, i.e., anyone who wants to pray in it is not to be prevented from doing so
3- It is established for the purpose of offering the five daily prayers regularly and on a permanent basis.
For that, Akram Jomaa Islamic Centre is considered a masjid since it meets the above conditions.
And Allah knows best.
Question Date: 2012-06-29
* The views posted are the opinions of the individual author of each posting, and are solely meant for education, discussion, and debate, not for any illegal purpose. The authors are not responsible or liable for the intentional, reckless, or negligent actions of any individual, and we assumes no responsibility for the content of the authors. Thus, the articles and materials posted do not represent, endorse or express the views of Muslims of Calgary or any of its affiliate organizations.
* Adhaan & Iqaamah if Praying at Home in Congregation (2011-02-25)* Adkhaar & Dua'a After Prayer (2010-10-06)* Angels Bowing to Adam (2010-08-02)* Asr Prayer Timing (2010-07-28)* Astrology - Will My Prayers Be Accepted (2013-03-27)* Cannot Maintain My Wudhu Due to Medication (2011-08-19)* Combine Evening Prayers Due to Late Isha (2010-06-11)* Combining Prayers Because of Snow (2010-11-21)* Concentration in Prayers (2010-02-11)* Conditions of Wiping Over Socks (2013-03-21)* Description of Eid Prayer (2013-10-13)* Description of the Prophet’s Prayer (2011-03-08)* Dhuhr and 'Asr Prayers together (2011-06-06)* Difference Between Fajr and Sobh (2013-11-14)* Difference Between Tahajjud and Qiyaam Al-Layl? (2012-11-21)* Different Times of Fajr Prayer (2011-07-09)* Do We Have to Pray Jumu'ah (Friday) Prayer? (2012-06-20)* Does Continually Passing Wind Invalidate Wudoo? (2011-08-25)* Dua’a in the Final Tashahhud (2011-05-31)* Du’aa’ in the Final Tashahhud (2012-09-27)* Earliest Time to Friday (Jum'ah) Prayer (2012-03-23)* Eye Surgery & Wudoo (2010-07-27)* Fajr Time (2010-06-12)* Female Dress Code During Prayer (2012-09-14)* Following Imam in Traweeh Congregation to Pray Missed Isha (2011-08-10)* Gas and Wudu (2012-08-14)* Gas Invalidates Wudoo (2011-01-12)* Giving Up Prayer Because Committing Zina (2011-06-24)* Holding Period Blood to Perform Prayer (2013-07-09)* How Does One Pray When Dealing With Health Issues? (2011-07-11)* How to Pray Witr (2011-12-08)* Husband Leading His Wife in Prayer (2011-02-02)* Hypocrisy in Prayer (2011-08-07)* I Do Not Pray Regularly (2013-07-08)* Iqamah Rasied While Offering Sunnah Prayer (2013-10-30)* Is Wadu’ Valid While Using Cosmetics? (2013-05-14)* Is work one of the excuses for which it is permissible to delay prayer beyond its time? (2010-01-06)* Is Wudoo’ Broken By Taking Off One's Socks? (2011-05-19)* Joining & Shortening Prayers (2010-07-26)* Learning Tahajjud Prayer (2014-03-01)* Loses Concentration while Praying (2011-11-07)* Maghrib and Isha Together (2010-06-11)* Maghrib Prayer While Working (2013-02-18)* Making Du’aa’ in English (2010-04-12)* Missed Prayers for 20 Years (2011-11-07)* Missing Prayer When Outside Home (2011-12-07)* Must Wash Feet or Wipe Over Socks Sufficient (2012-06-09)* Nafil and Fard Prayer (2014-03-13)* Nervious When Leading Salah (2013-08-06)* Parents Responses on How to Inspire our Children to Pray (2011-01-31)* Passing in Front of Someone Who is Praying (2011-03-10)* Performing Extra Prayers Between Obligatory Prayers (2011-09-17)* Performing Tayammum - Dry Ablution (2012-03-10)* Pillars and Sunnahs of Prayer (2012-01-31)* Prayed Toward Wrong Direction of Qiblah (2012-05-13)* Prayer After Sexual Intercourse (2012-11-04)* Prayer and IUD (2012-10-16)* Prayer in Dirty Environment (2011-01-22)* Prayers & Non-Muslim Employer (2010-11-09)* Prayers and Exams (2010-10-29)* Prayers During Travel (2010-06-11)* Praying at Home for Safety (2014-03-16)* Praying Fajr Before Its Time (2011-12-06)* Praying Istikhaarah in all one’s affairs (2010-03-06)* Praying Nafl (Voluntarily) Out Loud (Jahran) (2012-03-16)* Praying With Pad During Istihadah (2013-07-12)* Prevented From Performing Prayer in School (2011-12-25)* Quran Audio in Taraweeh (2010-08-23)* Raising the Hands for Dua'a (2011-10-07)* Raising the Hands in Salat (2011-08-10)* Reading From a Paper While Praying (2010-02-25)* Recite Surat After al-Faatihah in Prayer (2012-01-27)* Reciting al-Faatihah After the Imam (2012-10-25)* Reciting Few Verses that One Knows (2010-08-13)* Salatul Ishraq / Duha in the Sunnah (2011-12-08)* Saying “Amen” After Suratul Al-Fatiha in Prayer (2013-08-04)* Sleeping After Fajr (2011-04-09)* Spotting and Praying (2013-05-14)* Sujood al-Tilaawah (Recitation Prostrations) (2012-09-22)* Sunnah (Prophet's Example) in Performing Night Prayer (2011-05-22)* Sunnah Prayers Associated With Obligatory Prayers (2012-01-27)* The Change of Qiblah Direction (2012-11-22)* The Importance of Prayer (2011-09-20)* The Validity of Salat Ul-Tasaabeeh (2012-08-11)* Time for Duha or Ishraaq Prayer (2010-09-11)* Time of Zuhr Prayer (2010-08-14)* Times of the Five Daily Prayers (2011-01-07)* Tips to Concentrate in Salat / Prayer (2011-08-07)* Traveler (Safar) Prayer (2010-05-12)* Traveler Shortening of Prayers (2010-06-11)* Waiting Period to Pray After Birth (2011-09-15)* Wearing Leather (2010-04-02)* What is the Proof for Salaat al-Tasaabeeh? (2011-08-29)* When is it Permissible to Shorten (Qasr) Prayer? (2012-07-20)* Wiping Over Socks (2010-01-11)* Women Leading Prayers (2010-12-07)* Wudu & Baby Diaper (2010-02-25)* Wudu and Vaginal Discharge (2013-04-25)