Search all the listings in this section
Browse by Category:|
Is the Fajr time based on observation or astronomical calculation?
Praise be to Allaah.
Note that the time for Fajr prayer begins when the second dawn starts, which is the white line that spreads horizontally along the horizon right and left. The time lasts until the sun rises.
The first dawn is the false dawn, which is whiteness that appears vertically in the sky like pillars. This happens approximately twenty minutes before the true dawn, and it increases and decreases according to the season.
It is known that the rulings apply to the true dawn, not the false dawn.
There are many ahaadeeth which speak about the two dawns, such as the following:
The Prophet SAWS (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) said: “There are two dawns, the dawn when food becomes haraam and prayer becomes permissible, and the dawn when prayer (i.e., Fajr prayer) is haraam and food is permitted.”
(Narrated by al-Haakim and al-Bayhaqi from the hadeeth of Ibn ‘Abbaas; classed as saheeh by al-Albaani in Saheeh al-Jaami’, 4279).
And the Prophet (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) said: “There are two dawns. With regard to the dawn which is like the tail of a wolf, this does not make it permissible to pray and haraam to eat. With regard to the dawn which appears horizontally in the sky, this makes it permissible to pray and forbidden to eat.”
(Narrated by al-Haakim and al-Bayhaqi from the hadeeth of Jaabir; classed as saheeh by al-Albaani in Saheeh al-Jaami’, 4278)
According to another report, “There are two dawns. One is called the tail of the wolf, which is the false dawn that appears vertically, not horizontally. The other appears horizontally and not vertically.” (Classed as saheeh by al-Albaani in al-Silsilah al-Saheehah, no. 2202).
And the Prophet (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) said, “Do not let the adhaan of Bilaal stop you from eating suhoor, or the vertical dawn, but the dawn which appears along the horizon.”
(Narrated by Abu Dawood and al-Tirmidhi, who classed it as hasan. Classed as saheeh by al-Albaani in Saheeh al-Tirmidhi, no. 568)
From this explanation given by the Prophet (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him), we know that the definition of the time of Fajr is based on observation, not on astronomical calculations or on timetables whose authors are unknown as far as their trustworthiness and knowledge are concerned, especially if it is proven that they do not give the correct times.
This mistake does occur in most of the timetables. They do not give the correct time for Fajr and are based on the false dawn. This means that there is the risk that the Muslims’ prayers are invalid, especially in the case of those who pray in their houses immediately after hearing the adhaan.
A group of scholars and researchers in the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia, Syria, Egypt and Sudan have attempted to find out the time of the true dawn, and it is clear to them that the timetables in use at present are incorrect.
Shaykh al-Albaani (may Allaah have mercy on him) said:
“I have seen that myself many times in my house, and that enables me to confirm what some of those who are keen that the Muslims’ worship should be correct have said, that the adhaan of Fajr in some Arab countries is given 20-30 minutes before the time of the true dawn, i.e., it is also before the time of the false dawn. I have often heard the iqaamah for Fajr being given in some mosques at the time when the true dawn begins, and they give the adhaan before it is time. And they may hasten to do the fard prayer before it is time during the month of Ramadaan.”
(from al-Silsilah al-Saheehah, 5/25)
Once this is understood, the people from each town or city should appoint a group of trustworthy scholars to find out the time of Fajr and to announce that to the people, and warn them against following timetables if it is proven that they are incorrect.
And Allaah knows best.
Question Date: 2010-06-12
* The views posted are the opinions of the individual author of each posting, and are solely meant for education, discussion, and debate, not for any illegal purpose. The authors are not responsible or liable for the intentional, reckless, or negligent actions of any individual, and we assumes no responsibility for the content of the authors. Thus, the articles and materials posted do not represent, endorse or express the views of Muslims of Calgary or any of its affiliate organizations.
* Adhaan & Iqaamah if Praying at Home in Congregation (2011-02-25)* Adkhaar & Dua'a After Prayer (2010-10-06)* Angels Bowing to Adam (2010-08-02)* Asr Prayer Timing (2010-07-28)* Cannot Maintain My Wudhu Due to Medication (2011-08-19)* Combine Evening Prayers Due to Late Isha (2010-06-11)* Combining Prayers Because of Snow (2010-11-21)* Concentration in Prayers (2010-02-11)* Conditions of Wiping Over Socks (2013-03-21)* Description of the Prophet’s Prayer (2011-03-08)* Dhuhr and 'Asr Prayers together (2011-06-06)* Difference Between Tahajjud and Qiyaam Al-Layl? (2012-11-21)* Different Times of Fajr Prayer (2011-07-09)* Do We Have to Pray Jumu'ah (Friday) Prayer? (2012-06-20)* Does Continually Passing Wind Invalidate Wudoo? (2011-08-25)* Dua’a in the Final Tashahhud (2011-05-31)* Du’aa’ in the Final Tashahhud (2012-09-27)* Earliest Time to Friday (Jum'ah) Prayer (2012-03-23)* Eye Surgery & Wudoo (2010-07-27)* Female Dress Code During Prayer (2012-09-14)* Following Imam in Traweeh Congregation to Pray Missed Isha (2011-08-10)* Gas and Wudu (2012-08-14)* Gas Invalidates Wudoo (2011-01-12)* Giving Up Prayer Because Committing Zina (2011-06-24)* How Does One Pray When Dealing With Health Issues? (2011-07-11)* How to Pray Witr (2011-12-08)* Husband Leading His Wife in Prayer (2011-02-02)* Hypocrisy in Prayer (2011-08-07)* Is Akram Jomaa Islamic Centre Considered a Masjid or Musallah? (2012-06-29)* Is work one of the excuses for which it is permissible to delay prayer beyond its time? (2010-01-06)* Is Wudoo’ Broken By Taking Off One's Socks? (2011-05-19)* Joining & Shortening Prayers (2010-07-26)* Loses Concentration while Praying (2011-11-07)* Maghrib and Isha Together (2010-06-11)* Making Du’aa’ in English (2010-04-12)* Missed Prayers for 20 Years (2011-11-07)* Missing Prayer When Outside Home (2011-12-07)* Must Wash Feet or Wipe Over Socks Sufficient (2012-06-09)* Parents Responses on How to Inspire our Children to Pray (2011-01-31)* Passing in Front of Someone Who is Praying (2011-03-10)* Performing Extra Prayers Between Obligatory Prayers (2011-09-17)* Performing Tayammum - Dry Ablution (2012-03-10)* Pillars and Sunnahs of Prayer (2012-01-31)* Prayed Toward Wrong Direction of Qiblah (2012-05-13)* Prayer After Sexual Intercourse (2012-11-04)* Prayer in Dirty Environment (2011-01-22)* Prayers & Non-Muslim Employer (2010-11-09)* Prayers and Exams (2010-10-29)* Prayers During Travel (2010-06-11)* Praying Fajr Before Its Time (2011-12-06)* Praying Istikhaarah in all one’s affairs (2010-03-06)* Praying Nafl (Voluntarily) Out Loud (Jahran) (2012-03-16)* Prevented From Performing Prayer in School (2011-12-25)* Quran Audio in Taraweeh (2010-08-23)* Raising the Hands for Dua'a (2011-10-07)* Raising the Hands in Salat (2011-08-10)* Reading From a Paper While Praying (2010-02-25)* Recite Surat After al-Faatihah in Prayer (2012-01-27)* Reciting al-Faatihah After the Imam (2012-10-25)* Reciting Few Verses that One Knows (2010-08-13)* Salatul Ishraq / Duha in the Sunnah (2011-12-08)* Sleeping After Fajr (2011-04-09)* Sujood al-Tilaawah (Recitation Prostrations) (2012-09-22)* Sunnah (Prophet's Example) in Performing Night Prayer (2011-05-22)* Sunnah Prayers Associated With Obligatory Prayers (2012-01-27)* The Change of Qiblah Direction (2012-11-22)* The Importance of Prayer (2011-09-20)* The Validity of Salat Ul-Tasaabeeh (2012-08-11)* Time for Duha or Ishraaq Prayer (2010-09-11)* Time of Zuhr Prayer (2010-08-14)* Times of the Five Daily Prayers (2011-01-07)* Tips to Concentrate in Salat / Prayer (2011-08-07)* Traveler (Safar) Prayer (2010-05-12)* Traveler Shortening of Prayers (2010-06-11)* Waiting Period to Pray After Birth (2011-09-15)* Wearing Leather (2010-04-02)* What is the Proof for Salaat al-Tasaabeeh? (2011-08-29)* When is it Permissible to Shorten (Qasr) Prayer? (2012-07-20)* Wiping Over Socks (2010-01-11)* Women Leading Prayers (2010-12-07)* Wudu & Baby Diaper (2010-02-25)